Posted 19 June 2008 - 03:31 PM
Matt,
I figured that you would chime to whether or not you agree with me that Superman (and/or Hulk) would be hard to write for.
Chris
Superman is hard but has great writers at various times since 1986 (modern era for comics), John Bryne writing & art Man of Steel trades all 6 of them (hopefully more to come) + Superman/Batman Generations I & II have a special place on my bookshelf similar to the Peter David visionaries Hulk only that Peter David wrote Hulk alot longer than Byrne did, I liked the Death/Return/Aftermath of Superman from various writers/artists was a shocking change for over a year, Loeb run + Superman/Batman run + Smallville on tv, Superman writers just prior to Infinite Crisis -- Greg Rucka on Adventures of Superman, Gail Simone on Action & Mark Verheinden on Superman & Geoff Johns solo &
HOPEFULLY Johns/Robinson duo only time will tell on that though. But it had a share of clunkers, Superman Man of Energy + Red & Blue Supermen storylines & the Absolute worst Superman ever written in my opinon a miniseries called Superman Birthright (retelling of Superman origin that
I HATED sold it 3 years ago. I now realize Waid is a great Flash writer his first run (not his recent one on Flash), Kingdom Come, Brave & Bold are great but I would slap his hand so fast if he came towards writing Superman again & Superman For Tomorrow was very different coming from Brian Azzarello too. So writing for the Man of Steel is a great challenge but some writers can overcome the writer's Kryptonite to tell a amazing story for readers to enjoy. So as a Superman fan the movies writing wise goes, Superman I & II both A+ w/ extra credit given are the greatest & Superman Returns A- closest to I & II possible but falls just a bit short in my opinon, Superman III is just ok C-, & avoid Superman IV Quest for Peace at all costs a F for failure (
YOU HAVE BEEN WARNED! ). In closing, many writers (comics/movies/tv) try to write Superman but only a handful succeed at the task so that is a lasting testament of their skill as writers that make them "
The Great Ones".
Matthew
This post has been edited by mguy1977: 19 June 2008 - 04:28 PM
DCBS user:
I read in issues: Superman, Action Comics, Supergirl,Superman elseworlds mini, Batgirl, Sts. of Gotham, Adventure Comics, Legion, Power Girl, JLA, Wonder Woman, Zatanna, Fables, Amazing Spider-Man, FF, Hulk, Incredible Hulk, Uncanny X-Men, X-Men Forever 2, Walking Dead, Sweets mini, Hellboy, MouseGuard miniseries & Usagi Yojimbo.
Trades: Jonah Hex, Saga of the Swamp Thing HC, Walking Dead HC, Locke & Key, Hellboy/BPRD, Criminal & Astro City.
Have you read a comic today?